Peanut Butter Thumbprint – Grande (Set of Four)

Four intentionally oversized peanut butter thumbprint cookies, baked thicker for a softer, more generous center.

This set includes four of our Grande Peanut Butter Thumbprint cookies, each weighing approximately 85 grams and baked with extra thickness for a tender crumb and a more pronounced center.

A buttery cookie base provides structure and warmth, while a house-made peanut butter filling brings richness without heaviness. The flavor is familiar and comforting, balanced carefully so it never feels overly sweet or excessive.

Larger than our signature size, the Grande allows the texture and flavor to unfold more slowly. It’s a quieter indulgence — designed to be shared or savored one at a time.

Baked in small batches according to The Butterhouse Standard.

Size & format

• Set of four cookies
• Approx. 85 g per cookie
• Larger than our signature 50 g cookies
• Packed together in a single box

Prefer something lighter? Explore our Signature Cookies for a smaller, everyday size.